Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Comey Testifies that the President Broke the Law

Comey testified as follows:

(i) that he, OLC and the AG concluded that the NSA program was not legally defensible, i.e., that it violated FISA and that the Article II argument OLC had previously approved was not an adequate justification (a conclusion prompted by the New AAG, Jack Goldsmith, having undertaken a systematic review of OLC's previous legal opinions regarding the Commander in Chief's powers);

(ii) that the White House nevertheless continued with the program anyway, despite DOJ's judgment that it was unlawful;


(iii) that Comey, Ashcroft, the head of the FBI (Robert Mueller) and several other DOJ officials
therefore threatened to resign;

(iv) that the White House accordingly -- one day later -- asked DOJ to figure out a way the program could be changed to bring it into compliance with the law (presumably on the AUMF authorizaton theory); and


(v) that OLC thereafter did develop proposed amendments to the program over the subsequent two or three weeks, which were eventually implemented.


The program continued in the interim,
even after DOJ concluded that it was unlawful.



UPDATE:

This is simply mind boggling stuff and proof that Bush acted outside of the law even after he had been told that the programme he was engaged in was illegal.

Read Glenn Greenwald's take on this:
Yet even once Ashcroft and Comey made clear that the program had no legal basis (i.e., was against the law), the President ordered it to continue anyway. As Comey said: "The program was reauthorized without us and without a signature from the Department of Justice attesting as to its legality."

Amazingly, the President's own political appointees -- the two top Justice Department officials, including one (Ashcroft) who was known for his "aggressive" use of law enforcement powers in the name of fighting terrorism and at the expense of civil liberties -- were so convinced of its illegality that they refused to certify it and were preparing, along with numerous other top DOJ officials, to resign en masse once they learned that the program would continue notwithstanding the President's knowledge that it was illegal.

The overarching point here, as always, is that it is simply crystal clear that the President consciously and deliberately violated the law and committed multiple felonies by eavesdropping on Americans in violation of the law.
There is now a very clear case for impeachment. Even the Washington Post - as pro-Bush a newspaper as one could find - recognises that this is "an account of Bush administration lawlessness so shocking it would have been unbelievable coming from a less reputable source."

Tags: , , ,

No comments: